When to Quit a Race: An Athlete’s Guide to the Toughest Decision in Sport

Last weekend at Unbound Gravel in Emporia, Kansas, a combination of heat and strong headwinds put a lot of riders deep in the hurt locker and many had to the make the difficult decision of whether to continue or take a dreaded DNF (did not finish) - by Chris Carmichael, Founder and Head Coach of CTS

When to Quit a Race: An Athlete’s Guide to the Toughest Decision in Sport

I’m not a quitter, and I’m sure you are not either, but as the old saying goes, sometimes discretion is the better part of valor. Last weekend at Unbound Gravel in Emporia, Kansas, a combination of heat and strong headwinds put a lot of riders deep in the hurt locker and many had to the make the difficult decision of whether to continue or take a dreaded DNF (did not finish). Whether it’s heat, cold, fatigue, injury, mechanical failure, gastric distress, or a long list of other potential problems, if you are involved in endurance sports long enough you will inevitably be faced with the decision of whether to stop or continue, quit or keep going. And while we lionize those who persevere in the face of overwhelming adversity, and spend hours and pages expounding on the virtues of grit and determination, there is wisdom in knowing when it’s time to pull the plug. None of us wants to do it, so we don’t talk about how to do it, and that puts people at risk of hurting themselves or requiring others to come to their rescue. So, let’s talk about how to make good decisions on bad days.

Step 1: Plan Ahead

Preparation is the best way to avoid being in a situation where quitting is an option. Great fitness is your best advantage because it increases your capacity to absorb adversity before your performance suffers too much. Think about it this way, if you are barely fit enough to complete an event you don’t have the bandwidth to work through a serious setback. Greater fitness also means you can move faster, which reduces the amount of time you’re exposed to the elements.

Planning is also crucial for minimizing the chance you’ll face a go/no-go decision in the middle of an event. Examine the potential challenges you might face on course and carry gear that can help you out of a jam. For instance, if tire-slashing gravel is a feature of your event it makes sense to carry tools and supplies for tire repair. If you’re headed to high altitude and there’s even a remote chance of rain, carry a rain jacket, a skull cap and warm gloves (at minimum) so you can ride through a cold thunderstorm. Obviously a cyclist can’t carry a whole bike shop or wardrobe, but there are some crucial parts and tools that are small and easy to pack: multitool with chain breaker, master link, one set of brake pads (disc or caliper), one set of cleats (with screws), tube (at least one), tire boot and/or tubeless tire repair supplies, brake and derailleur cable (if running cables instead of electronic shifting and hydraulic braking). When it comes to inflation devices, you can carry CO2 cartridges to speed up the inflation process, but a pump is a safer bet in case you have multiple flats.

Step 2: Mentally rehearse responses to bad situations

From the comfort of your living room, conjure the worst possible scenarios you could encounter during your event. You want to play out these scenarios in your head with as much detail as possible. If it involves bicycle repair on the side of a dirt road, how long is the grass on the shoulder? Is the heat radiating off the road? Where are you going to put your tools so you don’t lose them?

Maybe your scenario is running out of water on a hot day more than hour away from the next aid station. What are you going to do? Can you drink from a stream? Do you have a filter? Can you ask other riders for water? If you can’t drink from a stream, can you at least soak your clothing to cool down and slow the process of dehydration? The point of mentally rehearsing your responses to worst case scenarios is to reduce the amount of stress you experience when you actually encounter challenges.

TrainRight Membership comes with a 30-day money-back guarantee!


Gran Fondo Guide fans, click on the image above and get TrainRight Membership for a 14 day no obligation trial. TrainRight Membership comes with a 30-day money-back guarantee!

Step 3: Set boundaries

It is important to evaluate what is at stake and your tolerance for risk. If your pro contract or lucrative sponsorship is on the line, you’re likely to accept a lot of risk in order to get a result. But the vast majority of endurance athletes are competing for fun and the pursuit of personal goals, and you have to set realistic boundaries for yourself in terms of the risks you’re willing to take. Personally, a finisher medal isn’t worth ending up in a medical tent, so if continuing is likely to end up that way I’ll take the DNF.

How to make the DNF decision on race day

When everything goes sideways on race day and you’re faced with the choice between dropping out and continuing, you have to take your emotions out of the equation and analyze the facts as they are. Your passion and determination are crucial components of your performance, but at this moment they can also lead you to make poor decisions that put you in danger. Here are some of the questions to consider:

- Is the situation dangerous or uncomfortable? Getting soaked might be uncomfortable, but getting hypothermia is dangerous. Riding in 100-degree heat is definitely uncomfortable, but may not be dangerous if you have water, ways to cool off, and you can still consume fluids without gastric distress. Riding with abrasions hurts, but continuing following signs of a concussion is dangerous.

- Do you have the gear necessary to continue safely? If you’re already cold and heading into conditions that will be even colder and don’t have the proper gear, you’re putting your health at risk. But if you have the necessary gear to stay warm and safe, then you can consider continuing. If you’ve exhausted your supply of tubes and tire repair options and already lost hours in the process, it may not be wise to continue.

- Can you stay adequately fueled and hydrated? Because of generous cutoffs, many cyclists and runners are able to continue and finish, even if that means going a lot slower than they hoped. But if an athlete is nauseated to the point they can’t consume fluids or calories, it is possible their stomach could settle with time but you have to consider whether they can make it to the next aid station safely.

- Will you put others at risk by continuing? If you are a danger to yourself or to the competitors around you, you have no business continuing. And while fellow competitors, event staff, and emergency personnel will help you if you need it, don’t knowingly put other people in a situation where they have to rescue you.

Non-negotiable reasons to stop

Sometimes the need to stop an athlete from continuing is obvious, but often it’s obvious to everyone but the athlete themselves. This is where a good support crew becomes invaluable, and where event officials have to be willing to be “the bad guy”. I have had to be the one to pull athletes from races. Although you only do it when all other options have been exhausted, it is still tough–even when you know it is the right choice for the athlete’s health and safety. I consider the following non-negotiable reasons for an athlete to stop: concussion symptoms, disorientation/confusion, lack of coordination, inability to consume food/fluids, persistent vomiting, or a physical injury that is likely to become more severe or increase risk for a subsequent injury if the athlete continues (running on a broken foot or riding with a broken wrist, for example).

No one wants to quit, and as coaches we do everything we can to ensure athletes are prepared to reach the finish line. But there are instances when taking a DNF is the wise choice. The key is to take the time to think through the process above so you don’t pull the plug too soon or unnecessarily.

Tag: cts
Oct 23 2021 - NEWS: How Little Training Can You Get Away With?
Oct 14 2021 - NEWS: The Scariest Things Cyclists Fear, And How to Overcome Them
Oct 02 2021 - NEWS: 7 Cycling Tips to Climb Any Hill Faster
Sep 22 2021 - NEWS: Cyclists: Leverage Late-Summer Power to Improve Your Pedal Stroke
Sep 16 2021 - NEWS: Decade-by-Decade Guide to Maximizing Performance and Health
Sep 10 2021 - NEWS: CTS Announces New 2022 Training Camps and Bucket List Experiences
Aug 29 2021 - NEWS: Seated and Standing Climbing Mechanics to Ride Uphill Faster
Aug 21 2021 - NEWS: The Best Cycling Workout to Boost Late-Summer Speed
Aug 15 2021 - NEWS: Three Training Rides Cyclists Need Every Week
Aug 03 2021 - NEWS: Can you handle the Golden State EPIC?
Jul 22 2021 - NEWS: Join CTS this September for their All-Inclusive Cycling Training Camp
Jul 27 2021 - NEWS: Olympic Coach’s Tips for Preparing for a Once-in-a-Lifetime Competition
Jul 14 2021 - NEWS: How to Pace Climbs Like Tour de France Cyclists
Jul 08 2021 - NEWS: Heat and Cycling: Performance and Safety when it gets Hot
Jul 03 2021 - NEWS: Masters Cyclists: Training Lessons from Mark Cavendish’s Return to Winning
Jan 16 2022 - EVENT: Maui Miles Cycling Experience
Feb 21 2022 - EVENT: Tucson Spring Training Cycling Camp
Mar 14 2022 - EVENT: Santa Ynez Spring Training Cycling Camp
May 04 2022 - EVENT: Brevard Road Cycling Camp
May 08 2022 - EVENT: Golden State Epic 2022
Jun 01 2022 - EVENT: Milan-San Remo Race Experience
Jun 28 2022 - EVENT: CTS Athlete House Camp Feat. Pikes Peak
Jul 19 2022 - EVENT: CTS Athlete House Camp Pikes Peak July
Aug 10 2022 - EVENT: SBT GRVL Cycling Camp
Nov 01 2022 - EVENT: Mallorca Fall Cycling Classic